๐Ÿ“š Harvard Must Read
Lesson 06 ยท Business Model Innovation

Four Paths to Business Model Innovation

๋น„์ฆˆ๋‹ˆ์Šค ๋ชจ๋ธ ํ˜์‹ ์˜ ๋„ค ๊ฐ€์ง€ ๊ธธ

๐ŸŽ“ Harvard Must Read ๐Ÿ“– Business Model Innovation
๐Ÿ“Œ Lesson Overview

Lesson 5 asked when a working model starts to fail. Lesson 6 turns to how to change one deliberately. Karan Girotra of Cornell and Serguei Netessine of Wharton (now INSEAD) argue that a business model is a set of key decisions about how a company earns revenue, incurs costs and manages risk, and that innovating on it means changing those decisions. They organize the ways of doing so along four questions: what, when, who and why.

A business model is a set of decisions

The authors open with a claim that is easy to miss: business model innovation demands neither new technology nor brand-new markets. It means delivering existing products with existing technologies to existing markets, and it can create advantages that are hard to copy.

Their working definition is that a business model is the set of key decisions that determine how a business earns revenue, incurs costs and manages risk. If so, innovating on the model is a matter of changing those decisions, and the framework gives four places to look.

๐Ÿ” Four questions about key decisions
What

What mix of products or services should you offer?

When

When should you make your key decisions?

Who

Who are your best decision makers?

Why

Why do the decision makers choose as they do?

Reinventing a business model does not have to be a series of isolated, internally focused events. It can become a continual, inclusive process.

โ€” Gist of the aim stated in Karan Girotra and Serguei Netessine, "Four Paths to Business Model Innovation" (HBR, Julyโ€“August 2014)
The four paths

The article's summary lists, for each question, a few concrete moves. I have kept them in the authors' order; the one-line glosses are mine.

1

What: recalibrate the offering

Focus narrowly, find commonalities across products, or build a hedge portfolio. The question is which mix of products carries the least risk for the same revenue.

2

When: change the timing of decisions

Postpone a decision, reorder decisions, or split a key decision apart. The point is to decide later, once more information has arrived.

3

Who: change the decision maker

Appoint a better-informed decision maker, assign a decision's risk to the party best able to bear its consequences, or choose the decision maker with the most to gain.

4

Why: change the motivations

Change the revenue stream, align time horizons, or integrate incentives. The aim is that those who decide want what the company wants.

Two kinds of risk behind the questions

In their INSEAD Knowledge piece (July 2014), the authors tie the four questions to risk. They describe information risk as arising from not knowing something, for instance which colour of iPhone 5 will be popular, and incentive alignment risk as arising when stakeholders' best interests diverge. Reading the paths through this lens is my own summary.

โš ๏ธ Two risks, and which paths address them
Information risk

Not knowing something that matters. The 'what' and 'when' paths reduce it by changing the mix of offerings or the moment of decision. (My reading.)

Incentive alignment risk

Stakeholders pulling in different directions. The 'who' and 'why' paths address it by changing the decision maker or the incentives. (My reading.)

Not a new market

None of this requires a new technology or a new market, which is why the authors treat it as a repeatable discipline.

A continual process

The framework is meant to make business model innovation a reliable, improvable discipline rather than a one-off event.

Lesson 6: Key concepts
Key 01

Model = decisions

A business model is the set of key decisions behind revenue, cost and risk. Change the decisions and the model changes.

Key 02

Four questions

What, when, who, why. Each opens a different kind of change: offering, timing, decision maker, incentives.

Key 03

Two kinds of risk

Information risk (not knowing) and incentive alignment risk (diverging interests) are what the four paths work on.

Key 04

No new technology needed

Existing products, technologies and markets can be enough. The innovation is in how decisions are arranged.

Insights from Lesson 6

Instead of asking what a new business model should look like, ask which decision to change, and who should make it.

Many problems that look like market problems are really timing or incentive problems. Moving the decision or the decision maker can change the result without changing the product.

A framework of four questions turns model innovation from inspiration into something a team can run repeatedly.

My Take โ€” Redesign the decision, not the company

What stood out most in Lesson 6 is that the unit of change is a decision, not a company or a product. Lesson 5 left us with the warning that by the time the numbers fall, options have narrowed. Here is a practical follow-up: a list of decisions that can be reopened at any time, such as what to offer, when to commit and who decides.

Lessons 1 and 2 described what a model is made of; this lesson gives four handles for moving it. The common thread is risk. Each path asks who is carrying which uncertainty and whether they are the right party to carry it. That is my reading of the framework, not a claim the authors make in so many words.

๐Ÿ“‹ Case Studies โ€” as described in the authors' INSEAD Knowledge article (2014)

CASE 01 ยท Blockbuster โ€” contracts with the studios

The authors cite Blockbuster's change to its contracts with movie studios in the 1990s, which let stores order more copies of the most valuable new releases and raised overall profits. They present it as an incentive alignment problem. Changing the contract changed what each side wanted to do.

CASE 02 ยท Diapers.com โ€” a narrow offering with predictable demand

Diapers.com launched in 2005 aimed at new parents. The authors note that demand for diapers is extremely easy to predict, which let the company manage costs at much higher efficiency. Reading it as an example of a narrow focus is my interpretation. Amazon bought the company in 2010 and let it run separately from the parent brand.

CASE 03 ยท Amazon โ€” reinventing the model proactively

The authors describe Amazon as changing its business model several times in its first fifteen years, moving from a 'sell all, carry few' system to a major wholesaler with its own warehouse network. They hold it up as proactive rather than reactive reinvention.

For me, the key words of Lesson 6 are decision and risk. If a business model is a bundle of decisions, then each decision has an owner, a moment and an incentive, and each of those three can be redesigned. The strength of the framework is that it is modest: it asks you to look at what is already there.

Before inventing something new, list your key decisions and ask of each: what, when, who and why. The answer may already be a new business model.

โœฆ Lesson 6 Summary

Girotra and Netessine define a business model as the set of key decisions that determine how a company earns revenue, incurs costs and manages risk. Innovating on it means changing those decisions along four questions: what to offer, when to decide, who decides, and why they decide as they do.

Each path comes with concrete moves, from narrowing the offering and postponing decisions to reassigning risk and changing incentives. None requires a new technology or a new market, which makes this a discipline a company can repeat.

References

Karan Girotra and Serguei Netessine, "Four Paths to Business Model Innovation," Harvard Business Review, Julyโ€“August 2014 (summary and introduction at hbr.org/2014/07/four-paths-to-business-model-innovation).

Karan Girotra and Serguei Netessine, "Four Questions to Revolutionise Your Business Model," INSEAD Knowledge, July 2, 2014.

Karan Girotra and Serguei Netessine, The Risk-Driven Business Model: Four Questions That Will Define Your Company, Harvard Business Review Press, 2014.

The examples reflect the situation as described in 2014. Circumstances may have changed since.

#HarvardMustRead #BusinessModelInnovation #Lesson6 #BusinessModel #Girotra #Netessine #Strategy #DecisionMaking #MBA