[Harvard Must Read] Business Model Innovation 05: When Your Business Model Is in Trouble
๊ฒฝ์์ ๋ต ๋น์ฆ๋์ค๋ชจ๋ธ ํ๋ฒ๋๋จธ์คํธ๋ฆฌ๋
When Your Business Model Is in Trouble
๋น์ฆ๋์ค ๋ชจ๋ธ์ด ํ๋ค๋ฆด ๋
Lesson 4 looked at the platform, one of the main shapes a new model can take. Lesson 5 starts from the other side: when does a model that works today begin to fail, and how would we notice? Drawing on the interview between Columbia Business School's Rita Gunther McGrath and HBR editor Sarah Cliffe, this lesson sets out the order in which warning signs appear, why they are so often ignored, and how to get through the transition.
McGrath gives three reasons for the surge of interest in business model innovation. First, everything is faster: product life cycles are shrinking, so a successful model expires sooner than it used to. Second, competition now crosses category lines, because customers can move their spending into an entirely different kind of product. Third, new models offer a better and more complete customer experience rather than a single product.
Her example of a good model is Build-A-Bear Workshop, where customers pay to make their own toys. In the same conversation she notes that conventional toy retail is down to about three large retailers. Those who sell the product and those who sell the experience have ended up in very different places.
What the customer actually pays for: a product, a service, a window of time. Change the unit and the model changes with it.
The set of connected activities that drive the key performance metrics, that is, what has to be done, and in what order, for the numbers to move.
CEMEX sells cement as a service, delivered within a specified window, rather than as a commodity. When the unit of business changes, the basis of competition changes too.
Changing a model means redesigning one of these two things, not polishing the product or the advertising. (My summary.)
A model rarely collapses overnight. The signals were there for a long time; we just did not read them as signals.
McGrath describes roughly three stages of warning. What matters is the order: the number everyone watches moves last.
Early: improvements get smaller
Each next generation improves less on the current product, and it gets harder to find new things to improve. The signal is very subtle, and the early evidence is usually brushed aside.
Middle: customers accept alternatives
Customers start describing other options as increasingly acceptable. You can hear it if you listen to them. Switching to cheaper rivals or buying less begins here.
Late: the financial numbers decline
Revenue and key performance indicators visibly fall. By McGrath's account, the company is by then already way down the road.
Even when the signals exist, organizations fail to move. McGrath points to three reasons.
Accepting the warning means denying a premise they have long relied on, so the threat gets read as smaller than it is.
Warnings often come from people without credibility or far from the strategy discussion. McGrath mentions her father, a senior scientist at Kodak who foresaw the shift to digital, and says leaders must go out and actively seek such information.
The better a model works, the weaker the case for change looks. While results are good, only the costs of change are visible.
McGrath is candid here. She has no magic formula, and she calls the transition period really, really tough. What she offers instead are a few practical tools.
Put a bare-bones net present value on new investments to see roughly when the cash starts to come back.
Get the cash out of your existing businesses first. If that is not enough, consider licensing, outsourcing, or selling an equity interest.
Public markets reward short-term results, which makes big write-offs or exits hard to sell. McGrath suggests patient investors, private equity for example, may suit a long transition better.
Once customers have been trained to expect something for free, it is very hard to get them to pay. She uses journalism as the example.
Unit of Business
What the customer pays for is the starting point of a model. Change it and the rules of competition change, even in the same market.
Three stages of warning
Shrinking improvements, customers accepting alternatives, then falling financials. The first two do not show up in the numbers.
Why warnings are ignored
Assumptions, the messenger's standing and the inertia of success combine to filter warnings out. The problem is less a lack of signals than how they are received.
Patient capital
Transitions take time. A capital structure judged on short-term results struggles to sustain a long one.
Financial metrics are the last signal of trouble. By the time the numbers turn, the options have already narrowed.
More often than not, a company fails to move not because there was no warning, but because it had no way to hear one.
The biggest cost of transition is time, not technology. Who will carry that time, and with whose money, has to be settled first.
What stood out most in Lesson 5 is that the first two of the three stages show up as what people say, not as numbers: a product team admitting it is running out of ideas, a customer remarking that the other product is good enough. By the time something appears in a report table, it is already the third stage. So responding to trouble is less a question of analytical tools than of who hears those words and whether there is a path for them to reach a decision.
This lesson reads better alongside the previous two. In Lesson 3, protecting the existing model while growing a new one required evaluating the two separately, and Lesson 4's platform showed where a new model might come from. Lesson 5 asks when all of that has to start. Begin after the numbers fall and there is no longer enough time to run two models side by side, or to build a platform. Timing is half of the strategy.
For me, the key words of Lesson 5 are timing and listening: when to start, and whose voice to hear. The more successful the model, the easier it is to put off both, because while the numbers are fine there seems to be no reason to change. But as McGrath makes clear, the moment the numbers are still fine is the moment with the most options.
The first to know a model is wobbling is not the report but the customer and the front line. The question is whether anyone is listening.
โฆ Lesson 5 Summary
A business model's trouble arrives in three stages: shrinking improvements, customers accepting alternatives, and falling financial metrics. The first two do not show up in the numbers and are easily dismissed, because of decision makers' assumptions, the messenger's standing, and the inertia of success.
There is no magic formula for managing the transition. Estimate the payback with simple math, fund the new from the existing business, and find patient capital to carry the long stretch. Redefining the unit of business is where it starts.
Rita Gunther McGrath and Sarah Cliffe, "When Your Business Model Is in Trouble," Harvard Business Review, JanuaryโFebruary 2011 (interview).
HBR IdeaCast Episode 224, "Build a Better Business Model," December 2, 2010 (host Sarah Cliffe, guest Rita McGrath).
Rita McGrath, "3 Signs Your Business Model is on Fire," January 25, 2011.
The examples reflect the situation around 2010โ2011, when the interview took place. Circumstances may have changed since.